MICHAEL MOSS – “Quantum Butterfly” (4CD-set)

Fourth Stream Records ERG-10014-5 / 4-CD Box Set / Street Date: January 15, 2027.
Jazz moderne
MICHAEL MOSS – “Quantum Butterfly” 4CD-set

Michael Moss’s Quantum Butterfly Review: A Lifetime of Jazz in Four CDs

Quantum Butterfly, the new 4CD-box from reed player and composer Michael Moss, runs for just over four hours across four volumes, and it never feels like padding. It feels like a life in music laid out on the table: a small combo burning through Coltrane and Ellington, a chamber ensemble of strings and reeds tackling dark, large-scale scores, and one hypnotic journey into electronics. Everything was played in front of a live audience between 2021 and 2025, and you can hear the risk-taking that comes with that. This is a great 4CD-set, made with love, and a set that rewards every minute you give it.

Michael Moss is a restless musician with a clear vision. He comes out of 1960s free jazz and the New York loft scene, learned bebop with Ben Sidran, then absorbed the breakthroughs of John Coltrane, Ornette Coleman, Cecil Taylor and Albert Ayler. In the 1970s he presided over the cooperative Free Life Communication, led the groups Four Rivers and Free Energy, played in Sam Rivers’s all-reed ensemble The Winds of Manhattan, and founded both Fourth Stream Records and ERG Publishing. He has also led the 22-piece Accidental Orchestra and has studied the folk music of the Middle East, India, Senegal, Japan, China, Thailand, Ireland and Romania along the way.

His “Fourth Stream” idea picks up where Gunther Schuller’s Third Stream left off, blending free improvisation, modern European composition, electronics and non-Western traditions into one open language. Quantum Butterfly is its fullest statement so far. Moss moves between tenor and soprano saxophones, B-flat clarinet, bass clarinet and flute (with a pungi, the Indian snake-charmer clarinet, on one piece), and his tone is personal and exploratory throughout. He never sounds like anyone else.

Volume 1: ROOTS to SHOOTS

The first disc introduces ROOTS to SHOOTS, Moss’s flexible combo with pianist and synthesist Alexis Marcelo, bassist Adam Lane and a rotating cast of drummers and percussionists, joined on several tracks by the legendary vibraphonist Warren Smith. The recordings come from live shows at venues such as the Bridge Street Theatre in Catskill, Saint John’s in the Village and Little Island in New York.

It opens with a joyous charge through Chick Corea’s La Fiesta. Moss’s soprano sings the melody out over a samba of grand proportions, while Caracas-born drummer Ismael Baiz, Marcelo and Lane drive the band forward without ever letting up. Moss’s own Coal Sack grows out of a Middle Eastern mode, swinging and strutting through a Coltrane-flavoured soprano while Lane’s bass adds darkness and Michael Wimberly’s djembe lifts the music into the air. Ellington’s Come Sunday is a gorgeous surprise: Moss’s bass clarinet, Lane’s mournful bowed bass and Smith’s vibraphone pay tribute to the composer and to the famous 1963 duo recording by Eric Dolphy and Richard Davis.

Sa La’am Mi / My Peace brings a North African groove into the very best kind of improvisation, and Mingus’s Goodbye Pork Pie Hat, one of his tenderest pieces, is handled with as much reverence as invention. Moss’s bluesy tenor and Smith’s mournful vibes lift it to another level.

Then comes Amitabha, a Moss original named after the Sanskrit for “boundless radiance”. A beautifully unsettling soprano melody dances over odd meters, Lane’s astonishingly fast bassline explodes into a freer, more intense section, and Wimberly’s percussion tangles happily with Baiz’s drum kit. As the piece closes, Warren Smith leaves the vibraphone for the drums and delivers a solo for the ages. He was 87 years old at the time, yet he plays with fierce dynamics, tenacity and sheer virtuosity. The moment is historic, and it is only one of many on this set.

The disc ends with two spiritual-inspired pieces: Margaret Douroux’s I Don’t Want No Trouble at the River, with Moss on flute and the soulful voice of gospel and R&B singer Bobby Harden, and Harden’s own What Do You Call It? I Call It Love. It is a fitting way to close.

Volume 2: Ensemble Bows for Strings, Piano and Reeds

The second disc moves into a different world, and it is a thrilling one. Moss founded Ensemble Bows in the spirit of his old “third stream” experiments, and it is an all-star gathering of strings, piano and reeds. The first two pieces feature the 2023 line-up of violinists Rosi Hertlein and Sunjay Jayaram, violist Melanie Dyer, cellist Lenny Mims, bassist Ken Filiano and pianist Anthony Coleman, with Moss on B-flat clarinet.

Abyss is the centrepiece, a masterwork of more than nineteen minutes recorded at Westbeth in Greenwich Village. It sizzles into storm clouds that bring Stravinsky, Shostakovich and Hanns Eisler to mind. The music has a deeply personal source: Moss began it while caring for his father-in-law, a Holocaust survivor, during the last seven months of his life. Built on a sestina by Louisa Bieler and on passages from Leviticus and Jeremiah, it expresses the pain and suffering of humanity, and it carries that weight with great power.

Far Away (Opus 89) is the world premiere of a work by the acclaimed Romanian composer Sorin Lerescu, written especially for Moss and Ensemble Bows. It develops slowly, with chromatic invention and icy string passages around Coleman’s piano, and Ken Filiano’s bass stands out in the dark atmosphere. The last two pieces come from a 2022 concert at Saint John’s in the Village with a different line-up that includes violinists Trina Basu, Sana Nagano and Liz Taub, violists Alexandra Honigsberg and Jon Kass, cellist Jake Charkey, bassist Ratzo Harris and pianist Marcelo. Elegy for Danny honours Moss’s late brother-in-law Daniel Canner and travels through several shades of darkness and lament. Ain Soph, named for the Hebrew term for “infinite”, has a distant, rhythmic theme for woodwinds, with pungi and bass clarinet thickening the harmony. The result is an almost dizzying piece that evokes a vast desert under a blazing sun, with a hypnotic, minimalist allure and shimmering free sections.

Volume 3: Quantum Butterfly

The third disc starts with swinging quartet music and ends on the set’s boldest adventure. Samson’s Walk, recorded at the Bridge Street Theatre, has that old Blue Note feel. Moss delivers one of his fattest tenor solos, with Marcelo on electric piano, Lane on bass and drummer Myron Cohen, who played with Moss in the R&B band The Fabulous Imitations back in the early 1960s. Freedom Chant is an immediately tuneful original that nods to Coltrane. Lane’s solo moves from pizzicato to a growling, howling arco passage, and Ismael Baiz’s rolling drum solo, with layers of samba and mambo cross-rhythms, is a feat in itself.

Then comes the title piece, Quantum Butterfly/ Adjacent Possibles, nearly twenty-five minutes long, a collaboration with composer James Dashow, a pioneer of digital audio synthesis. The ROOTS to SHOOTS quartet plays against Dashow’s raining electronic music, which in the original performance moved around the hall through six speakers. It sounds like the soundtrack to a futuristic film we have not yet seen. Lane’s arco improvisation starts cello-like and melismatic before sinking into deep, pulsing harmonic darkness beneath Moss’s bass clarinet, and a soulful, contrapuntal arrangement inspired by Leon Thomas’s The Creator Has a Master Plan anchors the electronics. Mixing electronics with free improvisation is not new, but here it is especially moving, and in the second half of the piece the atmosphere itself seems to become an instrument. Audiophiles with an Atmos system can even place themselves in the center of the sound.

Volume 4: ROOTS to SHOOTS at Westbeth

The last disc captures a sold-out concert in September 2025 at the Westbeth Center for the Arts. It had been planned years earlier, was sidelined by the pandemic, and arrived as a compendium of Moss’s whole life in music. Jackson Krall joins the band on drums, and Warren Smith, now 91, is still shimmering on the vibraphone.

Dolphy’s Left Alone opens the show, with Moss’s flute floating over vibes, piano and cymbals in moods that are both pensive and quietly stormy. Coltrane’s Afro Blue follows, its strong melody carried by rolling rhythm. Smith takes the first driving solo, with a four-mallet shimmer that recalls Bobby Hutcherson, and Marcelo answers with a two-fisted piano solo that movingly recalls McCoy Tyner. Bill Evans’s T.T.T.T., which Moss describes as Evans’s attempt to write in a Schoenbergian manner, is built on a tone row that Moss reworks into retrograde and beyond. Once at tempo, it becomes a very listenable jazz head.

Moss’s elegant tenor leads Equinox, refusing to simply copy Coltrane while giving him all the respect he is due, and Krall’s free-flowing drumming catches much of Elvin Jones’s ceaseless thunder. A subtle, sensitive Come Sunday settles the mood, and Syeeda’s Flute Song shows how this music, harmonically challenging more than sixty years later, still sounds effortless in the hands of this band. The concert closes with Coltrane’s Transition and Moss’s own March On, a piece that would not have been out of place in Sonny Rollins’s Freedom Suite. A thriving repeated riff leads to a whispery Smith vibraphone solo of glimmering dyads, then to a definitive Marcelo solo that moves between mid-1950s blue funkiness and fiery triple-time. When Moss returns, his statement captures the fascinating transitional period in jazz history that shaped his own formative years.

What holds the whole 4CD-box together is the quality of the musicians. Warren Smith, whose career runs from Miles Davis and Charles Mingus to Janis Joplin and Van Morrison, is a thrilling presence on the vibraphone and drums at an age when most players have long retired. Alexis Marcelo moves with ease from Chick Corea-style electric piano to Tyner-like chords, and Adam Lane’s bass, whether bowed or plucked, is a constant source of surprise. Ismael Baiz, Jackson Krall, Myron Cohen and Michael Wimberly each bring their own rhythmic personality, Bobby Harden adds a spiritual voice, and the string players of Ensemble Bows give the written music its depth and bite. At the centre is Moss himself, a leader who has the confidence to share the spotlight and the curiosity to keep moving forward.

Quantum Butterfly shows a musician with nothing left to prove who still plays as though he has everything to discover. For Moss, the aim is a music with no boundaries, in which everything connects, from folk traditions and the blues to Schoenberg, Coltrane and electronics. These four volumes make that idea convincing and moving. Every track was played live, in front of an audience, and the freedom of the performances is audible from the first note to the last. Four hours is a lot of music, but this is a set to live with, to return to, and to explore volume by volume. It is generous, adventurous, deeply human and full of love for the music. A really GREAT 4CD-boxset!

Frankie Pfeiffer
Editor in chief – PARIS-MOVE

PARIS-MOVE, November 22nd, 2026

Follow PARIS-MOVE on X

::::::::::::::::::::: 

Order the CDs on the Bandcamp  https://michaelmoss.bandcamp.com/

Tracklisting.

QUANTUM BUTTERFLY Vol.1 : ROOTS to SHOOTS

  1. La Fiesta 10:39
  2. Coal Sack 09:19
  3. Come Sunday 10:40
  4. 4. Sa La’am Mi/My Peace 10:51
  5. Goodbye Porkpie Hat 06:52
  6. Amitabha–>Warren Smith Drum Solo 12:42
  7. I Don’t Want No Trouble at the River 07:38
  8. What Do You Call It? I Call It Love 06:02

QUANTUM BUTTERFLY Vol.2: Ensemble Bows for Strings, Piano and Reeds

  1. Abyss 19:05
  2. Far Away 11:07
  3. Elegy for Danny 08:25
  4. Ain Soph 20:21

QUANTUM BUTTERFLY Vol.3

  1. Samson’s Walk 08:49
  2. Freedom Chant 13:24
  3. Quantum Butterfly/Adjacent Possibles 24:51

QUANTUM BUTTERFLY Vol.4 : ROOTS to SHOOTS

  1. Left Alone 09:01
  2. Afro Blue 05:55
  3. T.T.T.T. 08:31
  4. Equinox 12:03
  5. Come Sunday 07:38
  6. Syeeda’s Flute Song 10:31
  7. Transition 10:23
  8. March On 07:58

Musicians:
Michael Moss: tenor & soprano saxophones, flute, Bb clarinet, bass clarinet, snake charmer
Warren Smith: vibraphone & drums
Anthony Coleman: piano
Alexis Marcelo: piano & synthesizer
Trina Basu: violin
Rosi Hertlein: violin
Sunjay Jayaram: violin
Sana Nagano: violin
Liz Taub: violin
Melanie Dyer: viola
Alexandra Honigsberg: viola
Jon Kass: viola
Jake Charkey: cello
Lenny Mims: cello
Ken Filiano: bass
Adam Lane: bass
Ratzo Harris: contrabass
Myron Cohen: drums
Jackson Krall: drums
Ismael Baiz: drums & percussion
Michael Wimberly: piano & percussion
Bobby Harden: vocals